The Flemish Beerdrinker. Ivan's weblog.
   

Ivan's weblog

Me - Ik

In Flanders Fields

Archives - Archieven

2003
2004
01/01/2005-31/03/2005
01/04/2005-30/06/2005
01/07/2005-31/09/2005
01/10/2005-31/12/2005
01/01/2006-31/03/2006
01/04/2006-30/06/2006
01/07/2006-31/07/2006

Recent Posts -
Recente berichten:



Reading - Lectuur

Album

Contact

Hosting by:





My Yezzz





Zoeken



13/03/2006
Selective Globalization Syndrome

We all have it. Unfortunataly, there is still no cure for it:

LIKE gravity, globalization has come to be seen in recent years as an unstoppable force of nature. If the world is flat, capital, goods and services can go wherever they want. But last week, the process of cross-border economic integration suffered the same fate as foolish mortals who would defy Newtonian physics: it crashed to earth.

The furious fight over whether several port terminals in the United States should be owned by a company based in Dubai was resolved uncharacteristically and abruptly on Thursday. DP World, owned by the government of the United Arab Emirates, announced it would transfer the American operations of Peninsular & Oriental Steam Navigation, the British company it is in the process of acquiring.

During the port debate, opponents warned darkly of the perils of Arab control of vital industry in the United States, and advocates warned, equally darkly, of the perils of alienating foreign investors. But the maelstrom over maritime services is not the first heated exchange on the way globalization appears to pit national economic interests against national security.

Last summer, anguished protests stopped the Chinese oil company Cnooc from acquiring United States-based Unocal, even though Unocal slakes only a tiny fraction of America’s oil thirst. Indeed, the Dubai controversy is merely the latest manifestation of a new condition afflicting politicians, policymakers and ordinary citizens all over the globe. Call it Selective Globalization Syndrome.

The main symptom: a desire to pick and choose the outcomes of globalization, as if from an à la carte menu. For instance, nobody squawked in 2004 when DP World, then British-owned, bought the port operation of Florida’s CSX Corporation for $1.2 billion, or when a company based in Dubai bought the Essex House hotel in New York for $440 million last year.

Yet pro-globalization presidents and policymakers can be anti-globalists when convenient. President Bush, an ardent champion of free trade, has fervently argued for the ports transaction as a matter of principle. But he ordered protective steel tariffs early in his first term, and has shown little interest in exposing sugar growers in politically important states like Florida to the benefits of global competition.

Selective Globalization Syndrome drives politicians and government officials to even more seemingly contradictory stances. For instance, a Dubai-based company controlling East Coast ports is an unacceptable security risk, but Chinese companies controlling West Coast ports is fine.

The government body that approves such deals, the Committee on Foreign Investments in the United States, had no problem with China’s Lenovo controlling I.B.M.’s personal computer business. But it is examining the proposal by Check Point Software Technologies, an Israel-based company, to acquire Sourcefire, a Maryland-based software company that makes security products used by the federal government.

Selective Globalization Syndrome is also sweeping Europe. Political elites on the Continent may fancy themselves far less parochial and unilateral than their counterparts in the United States. Yet the prospect of foreign companies acquiring certain businesses inspires nationalistic angst. In Spain, whose banks have been re-enacting the conquista by acquiring rivals in Latin America, a bid from a German utility E.On for the Spanish utility Endesa has set off alarm bells. Apparently, the prospect of German engineers controlling the Spanish electricity grid is an insult to national dignity.

The United States, however, is similarly eager to dictate investment terms to non-citizens.

Buying debt? No problem. Foreign investors own more than half of United States government bonds. The biggest portfolios reside on the ledgers of China’s central bank and of various Saudi Arabian and other Persian Gulf government-controlled entities. But equity, which connotes ownership and control, in the same people’s hands sparks off Selective Globalization Syndrome.

"Our public is very concerned about a foreign country, in this case specifically a foreign country from the Middle East, having a major role in our ports," said Representative Jerry Lewis, a California Republican. But this is closing the barn door after it’s already been sold.

"The substantial majority of American containerized commerce is handled in U.S. ports by marine terminal operators that are subsidiaries or affiliates of foreign enterprises," said Christopher Koch, the president of the World Shipping Council, in recent Senate testimony.

Selective Globalization Syndrome causes politicians to lash out at symbolic issues they can influence, like the ports deal, because they cannot or don’t want to confront the root cause: the propensity of American government and consumers to buy more than they produce, to export more than they import and to borrow more than they save.

The United States runs a gigantic trade deficit, some $723 billion in 2005, which means it exports huge amounts of capital. But the foreigners who receive all those dollars in exchange for oil or manufactured goods are no longer content to park those greenbacks in government bonds.

"Why hold Treasuries that give you a mediocre 4.5 percent return over 30 years when you can instead buy higher return capital such as U.S. corporations, factories, ports and real estate?" asks Nouriel Roubini, an economics professor at New York University’s Stern School of Business.

Open borders and the free flow of goods and services across borders have created the conditions for Selective Globalization Syndrome to spread. And it may just be in its early stages.

Emboldened by their success at thwarting the Dubai ports deal, legislators are now more eager to challenge foreign economic interests in the name of national security. Members of Congress are falling over themselves to introduce legislation that would tighten the review process, requiring, for example, extended scrutiny of any deal involving a state-owned company.

But they had better hurry. The International Monetary Fund has noted that the world’s fuel-exporting nations will have a $533 billion current account surplus in 2006. That’s a half-trillion dollars for foreign countries, specifically foreign countries from the Middle East, to put to work in government bonds, stocks, real estate and, yes, whole companies.
>


Gepost door/Posted by: Ivan


Reacties/Comments


Comments are closed. Geen commentaar meer mogelijk.

Weblogs

 2blowhards
 A Fistful of Euros
 A Stich in Haste
 Abu Aardvark
 Adam Curry’s Weblog
 Adam Smith Institute Weblog
 AdamSmithee
 Always Low Prices
 AMERICAblog
 American Amnesia
 American Digest
 American Future
 Andrew Sullivan
 Andrew Tobias
 Angrybear
 Apostablog
 ArgMax blog
 Ashish’s Niti
 Asymmetrical Information
 Atlanticblog
 au currant
 Austro-Athenian Empire
 Backup Brain
 Balloon Juice
 Bearstrong
 Beirutcalling
 Ben Muse
 B-Expat Perspective
 Blame India Watch
 Boing Boing
 Bonobo Land
 Borrelpraat
 Brad DeLong
 Brad Setser
 Brad Spangler
 Bradford Plumer
 Brian’s culture blog
 Brian’s Education Blog
 Busfilm
 BusinessPundit
 Café Hayek
 Calpundit
 Catallarchy
 Chicago Boyz
 Chris Demeyere
 Chris Mooney
 Climate Audit
 Clive Davis
 Cold Spring Shops
 Conan the Libertarian
 Conservative Commentary
 Corante: Amateur Hour
 Corante: Brainwaves
 Corante: Connected
 Corante: Ideaflow
 Corante: Living Code
 Corante: Moores Lore
 Corante: Open Mind
 Corante: The Bottom Line
 CornerSolution
 Crescat Sententia
 Crooked Timber
 CUBA weblog
 Current copyright readings
 Daily Kos
 Daimnation!
 Daniel Drezner
 Daniel Hamilton
 David Galbraith
 David Holiday
 David Isenberg
 Davos Newbies
 De andere kijk
 De meningen verschillen
 Defense Tech
 Different Opinion
 Discourse.net
 Dissecting Leftism
 Division of Labour
 Dog of Flanders
 Downeastblog
 D-squared Digest
 Dutch Curry
 Dynamist Blog
 Eamonn Fitzgerald
 Econbrowser
 EconLog
 Econo Pundit
 Economics Unbound
 Economist’s view
 Edwin Jacobs
 Eject! Eject! Eject!
 Electrolite
 Entre Nous
 Environmental Economics
 EnviroSpin Watch
 Eric Alterman: Altercation
 Erik Dams
 Eschaton
 Fafblog!
 Final Protective Fire
 Flex Flint’s Favourite Fun
 Foreign Dispatches
 Francis Devriendt
 Frans Groenendijk
 Fredrik K.R. Norman
 Freedom to Tinker
 Freedom to trade
 Full Context
 Gene Healy
 General Glut’s Globblog
 GeorgeWBush.com
 Gerrit Zalm
 Global Growth Org
 Hans Wansink
 Harry’s place
 Hit & Run
 Hoegin
 Hypothetical Bias
 I am NoName
 I, Hans
 In Theory
 Insignificant Thoughts
 Instapundit
 Institutional Economics
 IPcentral Weblog
 Iraq at a glance
 Iraq the model
 Jay Solo’s Verbosity
 Jeff Jarvis
 Joel on software
 Johan Norberg
 Joho the blog
 Juan Cole Informed Comment
 Julian’s Lounge
 Jurgen Verstrepen
 Justin Logan
 JustOneMinute
 Karma Universe
 Kevin Drum
 kickAAS
 Kim du Toit
 Kurdo’s World
 Lawrence Lessig
 LeftWatch
 Liberty & Power
 little green footballs
 Live from Brussels
 LVBlog
 lying in ponds
 Macam-Macam
 macroblog
 MacroMouse
 Making Light
 Man Without Qualities
 Marc Cooper
 Marginal Revolution
 Marginal Utility
 Mark A. R. Kleiman
 Matt Welch
 Matthew Yglesias
 Max Speak
 Meaningful Distinction
 Michael Totten
 Mickey Kaus
 Mises Economics Blog
 Moonbat Central
 Moorewatch
 Mungowitz End
 Mutualist Blog
 Natalie Solent
 Nathan Newman
 neo-neocon
 New Economist
 Newmark’s Door
 nimbupani.com
 normblog
 Nouriel Roubini
 Obernews
 Obsidian Wings
 Oliver Kamm
 On The Third Hand
 One-Sided Wonder
 Outside The Beltway
 Overlawyered
 Overpopulation.Com
 Owen’s musings
 Oxblog
 pandagon
 ParaPundit
 Passion of the Present
 Patricia Ceysens
 Pedantry
 Pejmanesque
 Peter Gordon
 PFF Blog
 Pieter Cleppe
 PoliPundit
 Politiekblog
 Politiekincorrect
 Prestopundit
 Priorities & Frivolities
 ProfessorBainbridge
 Protein wisdom
 PSD Blog
 Pub Philosopher
 Publius Pundit
 Random Notes
 Rasmusen Weblog
 RealClear Politics
 Regnum Crucis
 Release 4.0
 Republikeinse Weblog
 Right As Usual
 Right Wing News
 road of a nation
 Roger L. Simon
 Rudi De Kerpel
 samaBlog
 Samizdata
 SaraGrace
 SATN.org
 SBlog
 schrillblog
 Sifry’s Alerts
 Simon World
 Skender
 Slugger O’Toole
 Speels Maar Serieus
 Spinsanity
 Stefan Geens
 Stephen Pollard
 Steve Verdon
 Stu’s Weblog
 Stumbling and Mumbling
 Sun of Iraq
 Tacitus
 Taking Hayek Seriously
 Talking Points Memo
 Tapped
 The Acorn
 The American Scene
 The Becker-Posner Blog
 The Belgravia Dispatch
 The Big Picture
 The Black Line
 The Brussels Journal
 The Commons
 The Complex Now
 The Conspiracy to Keep you Poor and Stupid
 The Corner
 The Decembrist
 The Doc Searls Weblog
 The Early Days of a Better Nation
 The Econoclast
 The Edge of England’s Sword
 The Greatest Jeneration
 the idea shop
 The Karmic Inquisition
 The Knowledge Problem
 The Kolkata Libertarian
 The Liberty Log
 The Long Harvest
 The Long Tail
 The Noble Pundit
 The Periscope
 The Perpetual Three-Dot Column
 The Poor Man
 The Pulpmovies weblog
 The Road to Euro Serfdom
 the road to surfdom
 The Technology Liberation Front
 The Truth Laid Bear
 The Volokh Conspiracy
 The Welfare State We’re In
 TheAgitator
 This Blog Sits at the...
 Thomas P.M. Barnett
 Tim Blair
 Tim Worstall
 To the Tooting Station
 Trade Diversion
 Trendmacro
 Truck and Barter
 T-Salon
 Unqualified Offerings
 USS Clueless
 Val e-diction
 Venture Blog
 Veritas et Venustas
 VH’s Fleyeing Circus
 Vice Squad
 Vox Baby
 Vrijhaven
 Wagner’s Weblog
 Werblog
 whoknew
 Will Wilkinson
 William J. Polley
 Winds of Change
 Winterspeak
 Witte sokken
 Wonkette

Reviews

 Accuracy In Media
 Antiwar
 Arts & Letters Daily
 Business Daily Review
 Butterflies and Wheels
 CalTrade Report
 Capitalist Chicks
 China Digital News
 Drudge Report
 euro-correspondent.com
 Free Market News Network
 Globalisation Guide
 Globalisering.com
 HonestReporting
 Human Nature Daily Review
 Political Theory Daily Review
 Project Syndicate
 RISQ: International Social Questions
 SciTech Daily Review
 secularislam
 Tomalak’s Realm
 Urban Legends Reference Pages
 Useit.com:Jakob Nielsen
 Webwereld. ICT-nieuws
 WorldNetDaily

Kranten - Magazines

 Alternet
 Brainwash
 Bulleton of the Atomic Scientists
 Business 2.0
 Business Report
 BusinessWeek
 Christian Science Monitor
 City Journal
 Commentary Magazine
 Counterpunch
 De Standaard
 De Tijd
 Delirra
 Dissent Magazine
 Economic and Political Weekly
 eWeek
 First Monday
 firstofthemonth
 Forbes
 Foreign Policy
 Fortune
 Frontpage Mag
 Google News
 Haaretz
 Harvard Magazine
 History News Network
 History Today
 In These Times
 Left Business Observer
 London Review of Books
 Los Angeles Times
 Middle East Intelligence Bulletin
 Monthly Review
 National Journal
 National Post
 National Review
 nature
 New Internationalist magazine
 New Left Review
 Newsweek
 Newtopia Magazine
 Open Democracy
 Pacific News Service
 Palistine Chronicle
 Parameters
 Partisan Review
 Physics Today
 Prospect Magazine
 Reason
 Red Herring
 Sierra Times
 Silicon Valley
 Slate
 Spiked
 Tech Central Station
 Tech Central Station Europe
 Technology Review
 The American Prospect
 The American Spectator
 The Atlantic
 The Economic Times
 The Economist
 The Economists’ Voice
 The Guardian
 The International Economy Magazine
 The Nation
 The New Republic
 The New York Observer
 The New York Review of Books
 The New York Times
 The New Yorker
 The Public Interest
 The Region
 The Spectator
 The Village Voice
 The Washington Monthly
 The Washington Post
 The Weekly Standard
 TheStreet
 Time
 Trends
 Wilson Quarterly
 Wired
 World Policy Journal
 WRMEA
 Z Magazine
 Zdnet

Columnisten

 Caroline Baum
 Christopher Hitchens
 Clay Shirky’s Internet Writings
 Daniel Pipes
 David Broder
 David Warren
 George Monbiot
 Jim Hoagland
 Johann Hari
 Jonathan Rauch
 Mark Steyn
 Martin Shaw
 Michael Fumento
 Michael Moore
 Norah Vincent
 OpinionJournal
 Robert D. Kaplan
 Robert Kagan
 Robert Samuelson
 Robert Wright
 Ron Rosenbaum
 Ryan O’Donnell
 Samuel Brittan
 The New York Times Op-Ed Columnists
 Thomas Sowell
 Willam Shawcross
 William F. Buckley
 Workingforchange